top of page

GAF vs Owens Corning vs Malarkey: Which Shingle Is Right for You?

Writer: Ethan Rhoades
Ethan Rhoades
Nov 10
3 min read

Shopping for a new roof means hearing a lot of brand names fast. GAF. Owens Corning. Malarkey. CertainTeed. They all make good shingles, so how do you choose?

Here's a simple look at the big names, what each one does well, and why we install the brands we do.

First, the truth about brands

The shingle matters. The install matters more. Every major brand ties its best warranty to how the roof is installed and which matching parts are used underneath. A great shingle put on wrong is still a bad roof.

That's why we look at the whole system: the shingle, the underlayment, the starter strip, the ridge cap, the ventilation and the flashing.

GAF

GAF is North America's largest roofing manufacturer, and it's our main brand.

Its most popular shingle is the Timberline HDZ. A few things we like about it:

  • A wider nailing area. GAF calls it the StrikeZone. It helps every nail land where it should, and that's where wind resistance starts.

  • Strong wind coverage. When it's installed with qualifying GAF parts, it carries GAF's WindProven limited wind warranty with no maximum wind speed limit.

  • Algae protection. StainGuard Plus helps fight the dark streaks you see on a lot of roofs, backed by a 25-year limited warranty against algae discoloration.

  • Class A fire rating.

We're a GAF Master Elite contractor. That lets us offer GAF's System Plus limited warranty, which gives you 50 years of non-prorated coverage on a GAF Lifetime shingle system with qualifying accessories. GAF's standard shingle warranty only covers the first 10 years non-prorated.

Owens Corning

Owens Corning is another top name, and we're an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor.

Its Duration shingles use SureNail Technology, a fabric strip in the nailing zone that helps hold nails tight. They carry a 130 mph wind warranty and a limited lifetime warranty. They're a solid choice and come in a wide range of colors.

Malarkey

Malarkey is based in Portland, Oregon, so it knows Northwest weather.

Malarkey uses a rubberized asphalt it calls NEX in its shingles, made with polymers that include recycled rubber and plastic. Its Vista shingle carries a Class 4 impact rating, the highest rating under the UL 2218 test. That makes it worth a look if hail is a big worry for you.

CertainTeed

CertainTeed's Landmark shingle is a heavy, two-layer shingle with a nailing guide called NailTrak. It has a limited lifetime warranty, 15 years of algae protection, and wind coverage up to 130 mph with the right install.

IKO and PABCO

IKO and PABCO also make dependable architectural shingles, and PABCO is a West Coast manufacturer. They can be a good fit for some homes and budgets, and we're happy to talk through them.

Why we install GAF most

We've used all of these brands. We install GAF most because of three things:

  1. One system, one warranty. GAF makes the shingles and the parts under them, so the warranty covers the whole system.

  2. The warranty we can offer. As a GAF Master Elite contractor, we can register your roof for GAF coverage that only GAF certified contractors can offer.

  3. Consistent quality. We know how these shingles install and how they hold up in our weather.

That doesn't mean GAF is the only right answer. If you want a different brand, we'll walk you through how it compares.

Our three GAF options

To keep it simple, we offer three levels:

  • Base: GAF Timberline NS. A dependable architectural shingle at a great value.

  • Preferred: GAF Timberline HDZ. GAF's #1-selling shingle. Most of our customers pick this one. It's the best value for the money and the one we recommend for most homes.

  • Premium: GAF Grand Sequoia. An extra-thick designer shingle with a wood-shake look.

All three are installed to GAF's specs and local code, with all flashings replaced.

Learn more about our roof replacement service.

Not sure which is right for your home?

Every roof is different. We'll come out, inspect your roof, show you photos and walk you through your options. No pressure.

Comments


bottom of page